• Baked to order

    Every box is made after you order, never frozen ahead.

  • Ships nationwide

    Packed the day it ships and delivered fresh anywhere in the US.

  • Mom and daughter owned

    Kelsie and Cindy bake every batch themselves.

  • Farmstand now open

    Visit us at 3304 Cooper Rd, Plant City, or choose pickup at checkout.

Now open

Visit our farmstand

Our farmstand is now open at 3304 Cooper Rd in Plant City, FL. Stop by for our stuffed cookies, sourdough bread, homemade jams, and other treats, or order cookies online for local pickup or nationwide shipping.

Farmstand address

Crushin' on Cookies
3304 Cooper Rd
Plant City, FL 33565
Get directions

Farmstand hours

Wednesday: 11am–7pm
Thursday–Friday: 9am–7pm

Order ahead

Our farmstand is now open! Stop by, order online for local pickup, or get cookies shipped nationwide.
Shop cookie boxes

Phone

(813) 730-1718

Find your perfect cookie match

Oversized gourmet stuffed cookies handmade to order in Plant City, FL. Four half-pound cookies in every box. Order for nationwide shipping or local pickup.

1 2

Let customers speak for us

from 18 reviews

Granddaughters loved their cookies, crushes cookies never lets you down! Looking for a sweet treat, orders your’s now !

Cindy

Loved all the cookies , always a big hit with the grandkids.

Cindy
Chocolate Cookies n' Cream Stuffed Cookie

10/10!

Nicole Bussey
Chocolate Cookies n' Cream Stuffed Cookie

Some of the best cookies we’ve ever had! Now they are my go to gift 🎁 choice

Laron Taylor
Campfire Cuddles S'mores Stuffed Cookie

Amazing cookies

Laron
The PB & O: Peanut Butter Oreo Stuffed Cookie

Great- something different :)

Jodi Stevens
Pumpkin Spice Cookie Butter Stuffed Cookie

Such delicious cookies! Everything was as expected and tasted amazing and super soft.

Xavier
Chocolate Fudge Fix: Gourmet Sweets Delight!

Love being able to give them so my grandkids can go get a sweet treat ❤️🍪🍦🍭🍓

Cindy
The Crushin' on Cookies Gift Card, Gift For Any Occasion
Great Cookies!

Great cookies! My daughter and I stopped in there today for the first time and loved it. Will definitely be going back

Betty T.
Great Customer Service

Very good customer service and very unique cookies and they were willing to give their time to explain each of their items with you

Laura C.
Massive Cookies!

Got the pumpkin one, it was delicious! Massive cookie can definitely share or split to eating more than one setting

Gladys C.
Highly Recommend!

I've been buying Crushin on Cookies for the past couple years as they started online before opening a retail shop this year. I have not been to the shop, but ordering online for shipment has always been a great experience. The owner is the sweetest too. The cookies have come a long way since the start and have a nice soft texture stuffed with goodness. My favorites include pops pecan pie, strawberry cheesecake (or any strawberry based cookie), oatmeal cream pie, maple syrup, caramel brownie, and cinnamon roll. Some are better slightly warmed up. Definitely recommend if you are in the area, if not, order for nationwide delivery!

Megan T.
Amazing Service!

This is a cute little family business. Very clean with friendly owners. They have stuffed cookies, cake pops and crispy bars. Maybe other treats but that is what they had today.
The cookie was delicious and is big enough to split.
The crispy bar is for my son but I am sure it is delicious too

Tracie L.

Peek inside

What's in the box

Four stuffed cookies per box, each about half a pound, individually wrapped, and packed the same day it ships.

Fan Favorites box of four stuffed gourmet cookies from Crushin' on Cookies

Fan favorites

Best Sellers Box

The four cookies customers keep coming back for.

  • S'mores: graham cracker cookie, marshmallow fluff, melted milk chocolate
  • Peanut Butter Butterfinger: peanut butter cookie with a creamy center and crushed Butterfinger
  • Cookie Butter: brown sugar cookie stuffed with Biscoff-style cookie butter
  • Cinnamon Roll: cinnamon sugar cookie with cream cheese frosting
Shop the Best Sellers Box
Chocolate Lovers box of four stuffed cookies - s'mores, peanut butter, cookies n' cream, and cookie monster

For the chocolate obsessed

Chocolate Lovers Box

Melted, molten, or stuffed straight through the middle.

  • S'mores: graham cracker cookie, marshmallow fluff, toasted marshmallow
  • Peanut Butter: chocolate cookie with a creamy peanut butter center and peanut butter cups
  • Cookies n' Cream: chocolate cookie with sweet cream filling and Oreo pieces
  • Cookie Monster: blue vanilla cookie stuffed with cookie dough
Shop the Chocolate Lovers Box

Sweet gifting made easy

Send a box to someone you're crushin' on

Add a note in your cart and we'll tuck it in the box. Not sure which flavors they'd pick? A digital gift card lands in their inbox instantly.

Shop cookie boxesGift cards

Good to know

Questions? We've got answers

How fast will my cookies arrive?

Every order is baked after you place it, and most boxes arrive within 3–4 days. We bake during the week and don't ship right before weekends, so your cookies never sit in transit.

How long do they stay fresh?

Cookies are individually wrapped and best within 5 days at room temperature. They also freeze beautifully for up to 3 months. See our storage and reheating guide.

What about allergens?

Our kitchen handles tree nuts, peanuts, dairy, eggs, wheat, and soy, so cross-contact is possible. Our cookies are not suitable for severe allergies. More in our FAQ.