Handcrafted Cookie Perfection from Plant City, Florida
Oversized stuffed cookies, baked fresh and shipped nationwide
Find Your Perfect Cookie Match
Oversized gourmet stuffed cookies baked fresh in Plant City, FL. Brownie, red velvet, s'mores, and more. Order for pickup, delivery, or nationwide shipping.
-
Mystery Box: 4-Pack Cookie Surprise
Regular price $30.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per$32.00 USDSale price $30.00 USDSale -
Brownie Pistachio Stuffed Cookie
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / perSale price $10.00 USD -
Cinnamon Roll Dulce de Leche Stuffed Cookie
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per$11.00 USDSale price $10.00 USDSale -
Red Velvet Oreo Stuffed Cookie
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price / per$10.00 USDSale price $10.00 USD
The Mother-Daughter Duo That Started It All
Kelsie started Crushin' on Cookies over five years ago with her mom Cindy. They spent a lot of time in the kitchen testing flavors and figuring out how to get a stuffed cookie to hold together without falling apart. What started as a home kitchen operation turned into a real business, and now they run their own cookie shop at 107 N Palmer St in Plant City, FL. They still bake everything in small batches and still argue about which new flavor to try next.
🍪 Save with our 4-Pack Bundle
Get more cookies, save more money. Perfect for sharing or stocking up on your favorites.
Let customers speak for us
from 13 reviewsSome of the best cookies we’ve ever had! Now they are my go to gift 🎁 choice
Such delicious cookies! Everything was as expected and tasted amazing and super soft.
Love being able to give them so my grandkids can go get a sweet treat ❤️🍪🍦🍭🍓
Great cookies! My daughter and I stopped in there today for the first time and loved it. Will definitely be going back
Very good customer service and very unique cookies and they were willing to give their time to explain each of their items with you
Got the pumpkin one, it was delicious! Massive cookie can definitely share or split to eating more than one setting
I've been buying Crushin on Cookies for the past couple years as they started online before opening a retail shop this year. I have not been to the shop, but ordering online for shipment has always been a great experience. The owner is the sweetest too. The cookies have come a long way since the start and have a nice soft texture stuffed with goodness. My favorites include pops pecan pie, strawberry cheesecake (or any strawberry based cookie), oatmeal cream pie, maple syrup, caramel brownie, and cinnamon roll. Some are better slightly warmed up. Definitely recommend if you are in the area, if not, order for nationwide delivery!
This is a cute little family business. Very clean with friendly owners. They have stuffed cookies, cake pops and crispy bars. Maybe other treats but that is what they had today.
The cookie was delicious and is big enough to split.
The crispy bar is for my son but I am sure it is delicious too
Fresh From the Oven: Artisan Bread has Arrived!
The wait is over. Our small-batch bread line is officially live!!
From the spicy Jalapeño Cheddar to our sweet Cinnamon Raisin Swirl, every loaf is available in both Classic Regular and Signature Sourdough styles. Hand-crafted, preservative-free, and ready for your toaster.

